2010 DAV Schools Competition Finals series
Playoff 1
Sacred Heart Girls College, Oakleigh
Wednesday, August 11th
A Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Star of the Sea College 2 | vs. | The Peninsula School 1 |
| Haileybury College Keysborough Boys 1 | vs. | Bialik College 1 |
| Cobram Secondary College A1 | vs. | St Monica's College 2 |
| Xavier College 2 | vs. | Kilvington Girls Grammar 1 |
| St Margaret's School 1 | vs. | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart 1 |
| De La Salle College (Kinnoull) 1 | vs. | St Michael's Grammar School 1 |
B Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| St Leonard's College 1 | vs. | St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 1 |
| Wesley College Glen Waverley 2 | vs. | Padua College - Mornington 1 |
| Sacre Coeur 1 | vs. | Wesley College St Kilda 1 |
| Methodist Ladies College 1 | vs. | Genazzano FCJ College 1 |
| Scotch College 3 | vs. | Whitefriars College 1 |
| Marymede Catholic College 1 | vs. | Brentwood Secondary College 1 |
C Grade - 8pm
That we should allow people to sell their organs
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Leibler Yavneh College 1 | vs. | St Francis Xavier College 1 |
| Avila College 1 | vs. | Haileybury College Keysborough Boys 1 |
| John Monash Science School 3 | vs. | Westbourne Grammar School 2 |
| Woodleigh School 1 | vs. | St Margaret's School 1 |
| Tintern Girls Grammar School 2 | vs. | Brighton Grammar School 1 |
D Grade - 8pm
That we should ban home schooling
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Haileybury College Keysborough Boys 5 | vs. | St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 5 |
| Genazzano FCJ College 3 | vs. | St Monica's College 3 |
| St Monica's College 5 | vs. | The Geelong College 2 |
| Lauriston Girls' School 2 | vs. | Elisabeth Murdoch College 1 |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Yarra Valley Grammar School 1 |
| Yarra Valley Grammar School 3 | vs. | Mt Hira College 1 |
| Woodleigh School 1 | vs. | Tintern Girls Grammar School 1 |
Playoff 2
Northcote High School
Wednesday, August 18th
A Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Yarra Valley Grammar School 1 | vs. | Emmanuel College 1 |
| Ballarat Grammar School 2 | vs. | Geelong Grammar School 1 |
| Carey Baptist Grammar School 2 | vs. | Penleigh and Essendon Grammar School (McNab) 2 |
| Girton Grammar School A1 | vs. | Princes Hill Secondary College 1 |
| Ivanhoe Grammar School 1 | vs. | Rochester Secondary College A1 |
| Melbourne High School 4 | vs. | St Helena Secondary College 2 |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | St Patrick's College 1 |
| St Bernard's College 1 | vs. | East Doncaster Secondary College 1 |
B Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Academy of Mary Immaculate 1 | vs. | Northcote High School 1 |
| Ballarat High School 1 | vs. | Melbourne High School 3 |
| Camberwell Grammar School 3 | vs. | St Kevin's College 2 |
| Gippsland Grammar School 1 | vs. | Westbourne Grammar School 1 |
| Loreto Mandeville Hall Toorak 1 | vs. | Melbourne Grammar School 2 |
| Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 1 | vs. | Xavier College 1 |
| St Kevin's College 4 | vs. | Williamstown High School 1 |
| Rochester Secondary College B1 | vs. | Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 2 |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Melbourne Grammar School 1 |
C Grade - 8pm
That we should abolish all academically selective schools
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Ballarat High School 1 | vs. | Northcote High School 2 |
| Camberwell Grammar School 2 | vs. | Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 1 |
| Loreto College 1 | vs. | Scotch College 2 |
| Melbourne High School 4 | vs. | St Kevin's College 2 |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Williamstown High School 1 |
D Grade - 8pm
That we should ban all junk food
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Genazzano FCJ College 3 | vs. | Mac.Robertson Girls' High School 3 |
| Lauriston Girls' School 2 | vs. | Marcellin College 8 |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Melbourne Grammar-Wadhurst 2 |
| St Monica's College 5 | vs. | Alphington Grammar School 1 |
| St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 5 | vs. | Keilor Downs Secondary College 4 |
| Woodleigh School 1 | vs. | Mercy Diocesan College 2 |
| Yarra Valley Grammar School 3 | vs. | Mazenod College 1 |
| Sacred Heart College Newtown 2 | vs. | Sacred Heart Girls College 2 |
| St Monica's College 2 | vs. | Santa Maria College 1 |
| Beth Rivkah Ladies College 2 | vs. | St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 2 |
| Eaglehawk Secondary College 1 | vs. | Strathcona Baptist Girls Grammar School 2 |
| Firbank Grammar School 2 | vs. | Wesley College St Kilda 2 |
| Ivanhoe Girls Grammar School 2 | vs. | Westbourne Grammar School 1 |
| Keilor Downs Secondary College 2 | vs. | Ballarat High School 1 |
| Mount Eliza Secondary College 1 | vs. | Kilvington Girls Grammar 2 |
| Sacred Heart College Newtown 1 | vs. | Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 2 |
Octo-finals
St Michael's Grammar School, St Kilda
Wednesday, August 25th
A Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Geelong Grammar School 1 | vs. | Melbourne High School 4 |
| East Doncaster Secondary College 1 | vs. | Kilvington Girls Grammar 1 |
| Emmanuel College 1 | vs. | St Margaret's School 1 |
| Penleigh and Essendon Grammar School (McNab) 2 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
| Princes Hill Secondary College 1 | vs. | St Michael's Grammar School 1 |
| The Peninsula School 1 | vs. | Avila College 1 |
| Gippsland Grammar School 1 | vs. | St Monica's College 2 |
| Haileybury College Keysborough Boys 1 | vs. | Ivanhoe Grammar School 1 |
B Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Wesley College St Kilda 1 | vs. | Gippsland Grammar School 1 |
| Melbourne High School 3 | vs. | Williamstown High School 1 |
| Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 1 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
| Northcote High School 1 | vs. | Brentwood Secondary College 1 |
| Melbourne Grammar School 2 | vs. | Methodist Ladies College 1 |
| Whitefriars College 1 | vs. | St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 1 |
| Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 2 | vs. | Wesley College Glen Waverley 2 |
| Kardinia International College 1 | vs. | Camberwell Grammar School 3 |
C Grade - 8pm
That we should reserve seats in Parliament for Indigenous Australians
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Academy of Mary Immaculate 2 | vs. | St Francis Xavier College 1 |
| Trinity Grammar School 1 | vs. | Tintern Girls Grammar School 2 |
| John Monash Science School 2 | vs. | Woodleigh School 1 |
| Northcote High School 2 | vs. | St Monica's College 1 |
| Scotch College 2 | vs. | Geelong Grammar School 1 |
| Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 1 | vs. | Girton Grammar School 1 |
| Melbourne High School 4 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
| Avila College 1 | vs. | John Monash Science School 3 |
D Grade - 8pm
That we should legalise commercial surrogacy
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Marcellin College 8 | vs. | Sacred Heart College Newtown 1 |
| Mazenod College 1 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
| Wesley College St Kilda 2 | vs. | Beth Rivkah Ladies College 2 |
| Alphington Grammar School 1 | vs. | Mount Eliza Secondary College 1 |
| Strathcona Baptist Girls Grammar School 2 | vs. | Woodleigh School 1 |
| Sacred Heart Girls College 2 | vs. | St Monica's College 2 |
| Ballarat High School 1 | vs. | St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 5 |
| Westbourne Grammar School 1 | vs. | Genazzano FCJ College 3 |
Quarter finals
Simonds Catholic College, West Melbourne
Wednesday, September 1st
A Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Melbourne High School 4 | (3-0) |
| St Michael's Grammar School 1 | vs. | Gippsland Grammar School 1 | (2-1) |
| St Margaret's School 1 | vs. | The Peninsula School 1 | |
| Ivanhoe Grammar School 1 | vs. | East Doncaster Secondary College 1 | (2-1) |
B Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Northcote High School 1 | vs. | Melbourne Grammar School 2 | (3-0) |
| Kardinia International College 1 | vs. | Wesley College Glen Waverley 2 | (3-0) |
| Melbourne High School 3 | vs. | St Paul's Anglican Grammar School 1 | (3-0) |
| Wesley College St Kilda 1 | vs. | Scotch College 1 | (3-0) |
C Grade - 8pm
That teachers’ pay should reflect the performance of their students
| Affirmative | Negative | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Lowther Hall Anglican Grammar School 1 | vs. | Scotch College 2 | (2-1) |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Academy of Mary Immaculate 2 | (2-1) |
| Trinity Grammar School 1 | vs. | Avila College 1 | (2-1) |
| Woodleigh School 1 | vs. | Northcote High School 2 | (3-0) |
D Grade - 8pm
That the government should take morbidly obese children away from their parents
| Affirmative | Negative | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Marcellin College 8 | vs. | Wesley College St Kilda 2 | (2-1) |
| Alphington Grammar School 1 | vs. | Strathcona Baptist Girls Grammar School 2 | (2-1) |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Sacred Heart Girls College 2 | (3-0) |
| Genazzano FCJ College 3 | vs. | Ballarat High School 1 | (2-1) |
Semi-finals
Ruyton Girls School, Kew
Wednesday, October 13th
A Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | St Michael's Grammar School 1 |
| Ivanhoe Grammar School 1 | vs. | St Margaret's School 1 |
B Grade - 7pm
Secret topic (released at 6pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Melbourne Grammar School 2 | vs. | Kardinia International College 1 |
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Melbourne High School 3 |
C Grade - 8pm
That Australia should process all asylum seekers in the community instead of offshore detention centres
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Avila College 1 | vs. | Woodleigh School 1 |
| Scotch College 2 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
D Grade - 8pm
That police officers who commit crimes should receive harsher penalties than ordinary citizens
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Genazzano FCJ College 3 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
| Marcellin College 8 | vs. | Alphington Grammar School 1 |
Grand Final
Caulfield Grammar School, Caulfield Campus
Thursday, October 21st
Please note that the debate times for the Grand Final are different to previous finals
A Grade - 4pm
Advised topic: Islam
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Ivanhoe Grammar School 1 |
B Grade - 8:15pm
Advised topic: Addiction (released at 7:15pm)
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Scotch College 1 | vs. | Melbourne Grammar School 2 |
C Grade - 7pm
That we should offer immunity from prosecution to terrorists who give us useful information
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Woodleigh School 1 | vs. | Scotch College 1 |
D Grade - 7pm
That denial of the Holocaust should be a crime
| Affirmative | Negative | |
|---|---|---|
| Alphington Grammar School 1 | vs. | Genazzano FCJ College 3 |